Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Kai He ( hekai@gzhu.edu.cn ) Corresponding author: Zhongzheng Chen ( chenzz@ahnu.edu.cn ) Corresponding author: Xuelong Jiang ( jiangxl@mail.kiz.ac.cn ) Academic editor: Clara Stefen
© 2026 Haixin Diao, Yuxin Xiong, Wenli Nie, Xiaoxin Pei, Wenyu Song, Xiaohan Wang, Kenneth Otieno Onditi, Hongjiao Wang, Quan Li, Xueyou Li, Kai He, Zhongzheng Chen, Xuelong Jiang.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Diao H, Xiong Y, Nie W, Pei X, Song W, Wang X, Onditi KO, Wang H, Li Q, Li X, He K, Chen Z, Jiang X (2026) Geographic isolation and climatic heterogeneity shape the genetic diversity of Blarinellini (Eulipotyphla: Soricidae) in the Hengduan Mountains. Vertebrate Zoology 76: 611-624. https://doi.org/10.3897/vz.76.e188776
|
Abstract
The Hengduan Mountains of southwestern China constitute a classic sky-island system shaped by complex topography and climatic history. We investigated the evolutionary history of the shrew tribe Blarinellini using 272 samples representing both genera and all four recognized species. Based on mitochondrial and nuclear sequence data, we reconstructed phylogenetic relationships, estimated divergence times, and examined population genetic structure and ecological niche dynamics. Our results support an early Miocene origin of Blarinellini (~18.2 million years). Population genetic analyses recovered five and four deeply divergent geographic lineages within Blarinella quadraticauda and B. wardi, respectively. Most genetic variation was partitioned among lineages, indicating strong long-term isolation. Lineage distributions closely correspond to major river systems and montane regions, suggesting that the effects of river barriers and sky-island fragmentation may have contributed to the observed patterns of diversification. Ecological niche models identified climatically stable habitats within the Hengduan Mountains across multiple glacial–interglacial cycles, whereas demographic analyses revealed recent expansion in a subset of lineages. Together, these results suggest that river barriers, sky-island fragmentation, and climatic change may have jointly contributed to diversification in Blarinellini, and suggest that evolutionary diversity within the tribe may be substantially underestimated. These findings highlight the dual role of the Hengduan Mountains as both a refuge preserving ancient lineages and a cradle generating new diversity.
Blarinellini, ecological niche modeling, Hengduan Mountains, phylogeography, Quaternary climate fluctuations, sky islands
The mountainous regions of southwestern China represent one of the world’s major biodiversity hotspots and harbor exceptionally high levels of species richness and endemism (
In addition to topographic complexity, the evolutionary history of the Hengduan Mountains has been strongly influenced by geological uplift and Quaternary climatic oscillations (
The tribe Blarinellini (Soricidae) provides an ideal model for evaluating how geographic isolation and climate change interact to shape diversification in montane small mammals. Members of the tribe are semi-fossorial shrews distributed throughout central and southwestern China and adjacent regions of Myanmar and Vietnam (
Recent taxonomic studies have substantially revised the classification of Blarinellini and currently recognize two genera, Blarinella and Parablarinella, comprising four species: Blarinella quadraticauda, B. wardi, Parablarinella griselda, and P. latimaxillata (
To address these knowledge gaps, we combined multilocus sequence data, population genetic analyses, divergence-time estimation, and ecological niche modeling to investigate phylogeographic diversification within Blarinellini. Specifically, we asked: (1) What are the phylogenetic relationships and population genetic structure within and among species of Blarinellini? (2) To what extent have river barriers and sky-island fragmentation contributed to lineage divergence across southwestern China? (3) How have Quaternary climatic fluctuations influenced demographic history and distribution dynamics within the tribe?
We examined 272 Blarinellini samples, including 127 individuals of Blarinella quadraticauda, 126 of B. wardi, 14 of Parablarinella griselda, and 5 of P. latimaxillata, representing both recognized genera and all four currently recognized species. Samples were obtained from 95 geographic localities, spanning most of the tribe’s known distribution (Fig.
Total genomic DNA was extracted using a DNeasy blood and tissue kit (Tiangen, China). We amplified and sequenced two mitochondrial markers (cyt b, 1140 bp; 16S rRNA, ~524 bp) and three nuclear loci (ApoB, ~516 bp; BRCA1, ~770 bp; RAG2, ~750 bp) by PCR, using the primers and annealing temperatures described in
We inferred phylogenetic relationships within Blarinellini using Bayesian inference (BI) and maximum likelihood (ML) approaches. BI analyses were conducted in MrBayes v3.2 as implemented in PhyloSuite v1.2.2 (
The phylogenetic reconstructions presented in the main text were based on a concatenated dataset comprising all five markers (cyt b, 16S rRNA, ApoB, BRCA1, and RAG2). This dataset was used to infer the primary BI and ML phylogenies and served as the basis for subsequent divergence time estimation. Optimal partitioning schemes and nucleotide substitution models were selected using PartitionFinder v2.0 (
For BI analyses, two independent runs, each comprising four Markov chains, were conducted for 10 million generations, with trees and parameters sampled every 10,000 generations. Convergence was assessed using the average standard deviation of split frequencies and parameter traces, and the first 25% of samples were discarded as burn-in. ML analyses were conducted under the rapid bootstrap algorithm implemented in RAxML, with 1000 bootstrap replicates to assess node support.
To assess the consistency of phylogenetic relationships across marker types, we additionally reconstructed phylogenies from concatenated mitochondrial (cyt b + 16S rRNA) and nuclear (ApoB + BRCA1 + RAG2) datasets —using the same analytical framework. Single-gene trees were also inferred for each locus. These supplementary phylogenies are provided in the Figures S1–S8.
We estimated divergence times for major nodes within Blarinellini in BEAST v2.7.7 (
We implemented two fossil-based calibration points using lognormal prior distributions. The first constrained the divergence between Blarinellini and its sister tribe, Blarinini. This calibration was based on the earliest fossil occurrence of Blarinini from the Barstovian of North America (~16.3–13.6 million years [Ma];
Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) analyses were run for 100 million generations, sampling every 20,000 generations. We conducted two independent runs and discarded the first 10% of samples from each as burn-in. Convergence and mixing were evaluated in Tracer v1.7.2 (
Because sampling localities for P. griselda and P. latimaxillata were limited, we conducted population genetic analyses only for B. quadraticauda and B. wardi. Due to missing cyt b data for one B. quadraticauda individual, cyt b-based analyses included 126 individuals of B. quadraticauda. Analyses were performed separately for the mitochondrial cyt b gene and the nuclear ApoB gene, which provided greater sample coverage than the remaining nuclear loci.
For each marker, haplotypes were identified and standard diversity indices, including the number of haplotypes (H), haplotype diversity (Hd), nucleotide diversity (π), number of segregating sites (S), and average number of nucleotide differences (k), were calculated in DnaSP v5.10 (
Haplotype networks for cyt b and ApoB were constructed using PopART v1.7 (
To evaluate whether the distributions of Blarinellini are consistent with long-term climatic niche stability, ecological niche models (ENMs) were constructed for B. quadraticauda and B. wardi using MaxEnt. Potential distributions were reconstructed for the Last Interglacial (LIG; 120–140 ka), the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM; ~22 ka), and the present. Occurrence records were compiled separately for each species from verified localities. To reduce spatial sampling bias and autocorrelation, duplicate records were removed and occurrences were spatially rarefied by retaining a single record within each 5 × 5 km grid cell. After filtering, 121 occurrence records for B. quadraticauda and 122 occurrence records for B. wardi were retained.
The background extent for model calibration was defined to approximate the accessible area (M) of Blarinellini, encompassing the known fossil and extant distribution range of the group, with the Yellow River as the northern boundary, the Indochinese Peninsula as the southern boundary, the Brahmaputra River as the western boundary, and the East China Sea as the eastern boundary. Nineteen bioclimatic variables were obtained from WorldClim v2.1 (
To reduce multicollinearity among predictors, variable selection was conducted in three steps. First, an initial MaxEnt model including all 19 variables was used to assess preliminary variable importance. Second, highly correlated variables (|r| ≥ 0.9) were identified using Pearson correlation analysis and removed. Third, variance inflation factor (VIF) analysis was used to exclude variables with VIF values > 10. Variables with consistently low contributions in the preliminary model were subsequently excluded. The final predictor set for B. quadraticauda included bio2, bio4, bio10, bio13, bio14, bio18, and bio19, whereas that for B. wardi included bio2, bio3, bio5, bio14, bio15, bio18, and bio19.
Model complexity was optimized separately for each species by evaluating combinations of feature classes and regularization multipliers. Optimal settings were selected using the lowest Akaike Information Criterion corrected for small sample size (AICc) and subsequently used for projections under present, LGM, and LIG climatic conditions. Final models were run with 10 replicates, using 75% of occurrence records for training and 25% for testing. Model performance was evaluated using the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC). All analyses were conducted in R v4.3.3 (
To assess distributional stability through time, habitat suitability predictions for the LIG, LGM, and present were converted to binary maps using a threshold of 0.5. Suitable areas (≥ 0.5) were overlaid across time periods to identify stable and unstable habitats. Cells predicted as suitable in all three periods were classified as long-term stable habitats (“Throughout”), those suitable in two periods as relatively stable habitats, those suitable in one period as unstable habitats, and those unsuitable in all periods as “Never suitable”. Following previous studies, resistance values of 1, 10, 100, and 1000 were assigned to these categories, respectively. Stability analyses were performed in ArcGIS v10.2. Variable contributions for each species are provided in Table S4.
Both ML and BI analyses of the combined datasets yielded highly congruent topologies, supporting the reciprocal monophyly of Blarinella and Parablarinella (posterior probability [PP]/ bootstrap values [BS] = 1.0/100; Figs
Within B. quadraticauda, five geographically structured lineages (Subclades I–V) were identified. The basal lineage (Subclade V) occurred in the eastern Yunnan Plateau and northern Vietnam, whereas the remaining lineages were distributed across the Yunnan–Guizhou Plateau, the margins of the Sichuan Basin, the Qinling Mountains, and the northern Yunnan–southwestern Sichuan highlands. Within B. wardi, four geographically structured lineages (Subclades A–D) were recovered. Subclade A occurred east of the Lancang River, Subclade B occupied the upper Nujiang drainage west of the river, Subclade C was distributed between the Lancang and Nujiang rivers, and Subclade D occurred in the lower Nujiang drainage.
Molecular dating estimated the stem and crown ages of Blarinellini at ~18.2 Ma (95% HPD: 21.6–16.5 Ma; Fig.
Bayesian inference (BI) phylogeny of Blarinellini reconstructed from the combined mitochondrial and nuclear dataset. Only major intraspecific subclades are shown. Numbers above or below branches correspond to Bayesian posterior probabilities (PP) and maximum likelihood bootstrap (BS) values, shown as PP/BS where the corresponding nodes are recovered in both analyses; for nodes not recovered in the ML tree, only PP values are shown. The scale bar denotes substitutions per site. Subclade colors correspond to Figure
Divergence-time estimates within Blarinellini based on combined mitochondrial and nuclear sequences. Node labels indicate median divergence times (Ma), and bars denote 95% highest posterior density (HPD) intervals. Red stars indicate fossil-based calibration points. The time scale is in million years (Ma). Subclade colors correspond to Figure
Analysis of 271 cyt b sequences identified 109 haplotypes (H1–H109; Table SS1). The median-joining network recovered four well-separated haplotype groups corresponding to B. quadraticauda, B. wardi, P. griselda, and P. latimaxillata (Fig.
Within B. quadraticauda, five distinct mitochondrial haplogroups corresponding to Subclades I–V were recovered. These haplogroups were separated by multiple mutational steps and numerous inferred intermediate haplotypes, indicating substantial genetic differentiation among geographic regions. Similarly, four well-defined mitochondrial haplogroups corresponding to Subclades A–D were identified within B. wardi. The distribution of haplotypes within both species showed strong geographic structure, with no haplotypes shared among major subclades.
Parablarinella exhibited markedly lower levels of mitochondrial variation. Parablarinella griselda comprised a compact cluster of closely related haplotypes, whereas P. latimaxillata contained only two closely related haplotypes. Despite their low internal diversity, both species remained strongly differentiated from Blarinella.
The nuclear ApoB dataset exhibited markedly reduced variation compared to cyt b and produced a shallow haplotype network (Fig. S9). Two primary haplotype groups corresponding to B. quadraticauda and B. wardi were identified, but several haplotypes were shared among mitochondrial subclades. Although overall geographic structure was weaker than in the mitochondrial dataset, a number of haplotypes were restricted to particular regions, especially within B. quadraticauda Subclades II and IV and B. wardi Subclade A.
AMOVA based on cyt b indicated pronounced population subdivision in both widespread species (Table
a Genetic distance (p distance) based on cyt b sequence data for Blarinellini populations. b Pairwise FST values among subclades of Blarinella quadraticauda and B. wardi based on cyt b sequence data. All pairwise FST values were significant (p < 0.001). Full pairwise p distance and FST matrices based on cyt b are provided in Table S7, and the corresponding matrices based on ApoB are provided in Table S8.
| Populations | Source of variation | d.f. | Sum of squares | Variance components | Percentage of variation | p value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B. quadraticauda (Subclade I–V) | Among Subclades | 4 | 447.468 | 4.86848 | 66.77 | p < 0.001 |
| Within Subclades | 121 | 293.175 | 2.42293 | 33.23 | p < 0.001 | |
| Total | 125 | 740.643 | 7.29141 | |||
| B. wardi (Subclade A–D) | Among Subclades | 3 | 587.099 | 6.73483 | 87.52 | p < 0.001 |
| Within Subclades | 122 | 117.115 | 0.95996 | 12.48 | p < 0.001 | |
| Total | 125 | 704.214 | 7.69478 |
Haplotype diversity was high in most subclades (Table
Mismatch distribution analyses for each subclade of Blarinella quadraticauda and B. wardi based on the cyt b sequences. The solid line shows the observed distribution of pairwise differences, whereas the dashed line shows the expected distribution under a sudden population expansion model.
| Species | Subclade | N | H | Hd | S | π | k | Tajima’s D | Fu’s FS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B. quadraticauda | I | 38 | 33 | 0.989 | 131 | 0.0298 | 33.186 | 0.0621 | −6.6448* |
| II | 10 | 8 | 0.956 | 28 | 0.0083 | 9.400 | −1.1614 | −0.5275 | |
| III | 49 | 22 | 0.855 | 29 | 0.0080 | 2.895 | −1.8209* | −12.2857** | |
| IV | 24 | 15 | 0.866 | 72 | 0.0092 | 10.428 | −1.9689** | -2.9205 | |
| V | 5 | 3 | 0.800 | 37 | 0.0184 | 20.800 | 1.7890 | 2.6780 | |
| B. wardi | A | 54 | 30 | 0.961 | 51 | 0.0050 | 5.391 | −2.0056** | −9.6325** |
| B | 10 | 7 | 0.933 | 34 | 0.0139 | 15.733 | 1.2797 | 1.0718 | |
| C | 33 | 15 | 0.919 | 34 | 0.0050 | 5.500 | −0.4387 | −0.5845 | |
| D | 29 | 21 | 0.963 | 66 | 0.0078 | 8.823 | −1.6675* | −2.6780 | |
| P. griselda | — | 14 | 11 | 0.967 | 33 | 0.0092 | 9.780 | 0.0420 | −1.2031 |
| P. latimaxillata | — | 5 | 5 | 1.000 | 13 | 0.0049 | 5.600 | −0.8165 | 0.0902 |
| Note: N, sample size. H, number of haplotypes. Hd, haplotype diversity. S, number of polymorphic sites. π, nucleotide diversity. k, mean number of nucleotide differences. Significance of neutrality tests (Tajima’s D and Fu’s FS): p* < 0.05; p** < 0.01. | |||||||||
Ecological niche models showed high predictive performance for both species (B. quadraticauda: AUC = 0.919–0.956; B. wardi: AUC = 0.987–0.989), and the predicted present-day suitable areas were generally consistent with the observed occurrence records (Fig.
Ecological niche model and climatic stability analyses for Blarinella quadraticauda and B. wardi. A–D Predicted habitat suitability and climatic stability for B. quadraticauda: A present (1970–2000), B Last Glacial Maximum (LGM; ~22 ka), C Last Interglacial (LIG; ~130 ka), and D long-term climatic stability. E–H Predicted habitat suitability and climatic stability for B. wardi: E present, F LGM, G LIG, and H long-term climatic stability. Habitat suitability values range from 0 to 1, with warmer colors indicating higher suitability. White dots show occurrence records of Blarinellini used in this study.
The analysis predicted extensive suitable habitat for B. quadraticauda across southwestern and central China under all climatic scenarios (Fig.
In contrast, suitable habitat for B. wardi was consistently more restricted and concentrated within the southern Hengduan Mountains and southeastern Tibetan Plateau (Fig.
Our multilocus analyses agree with the currently recognized taxonomy of Blarinellini, confirming the reciprocal monophyly of the four recognized species. The phylogeographic structure within both species, however, runs far deeper than current taxonomy reflects: we recovered five mitochondrial lineages in B. quadraticauda and four in B. wardi, with no haplotypes shared among major subclades. This deep genetic structure coincides with extensive chromosomal variation. The diploid number (2n) of B. quadraticauda ranges from 34 to 49 (
Our results are broadly consistent with the phylogeographic framework proposed by
The diversification of Blarinellini appears to have involved two major climate-associated stages (
Spatially, the diversification patterns of the two species appear to have been shaped by different landscape features, with a major biogeographic boundary coinciding with the distributional separation of B. quadraticauda and B. wardi. The boundary between the two species corresponds broadly to the paleo-Jinsha River, mirroring a pattern observed in the Chinese long-tailed mole (
Evidence for recent demographic expansion was detected only in B. quadraticauda Subclade III and B. wardi Subclade A (
Several limitations should be acknowledged. Although our analyses revealed pronounced phylogeographic structure and deep mitochondrial divergence within both B. quadraticauda and B. wardi, inference of evolutionary history was based primarily on mitochondrial data, with limited resolution from nuclear markers, resulting in relatively low support for some deeper nodes within B. quadraticauda in the nuclear gene trees. Consequently, the relative contributions of incomplete lineage sorting, historical introgression, and long-term reproductive isolation cannot yet be fully resolved. Moreover, while some lineages exhibit substantial genetic divergence and correspond broadly to previously reported chromosomal variation, the taxonomic significance of these patterns remains uncertain. Future studies integrating genome-wide, morphological, and cytogenetic data will be necessary to evaluate species boundaries and clarify the evolutionary processes underlying diversification within Blarinellini.
Using comprehensive geographic sampling across the distribution of Blarinellini, we reveal extensive phylogeographic structure and previously unrecognized evolutionary diversity within both B. quadraticauda and B. wardi. Divergence-time analyses indicate that diversification originated during the Neogene and that major intraspecific diversification intensified during the Pleistocene, whereas population genetic patterns and ecological niche models suggest that river barriers, sky-island fragmentation, and climatic fluctuations may have jointly contributed to lineage divergence and persistence. Although the current taxonomy of two genera and four species is supported, the deep genetic structure recovered within both widespread species indicates that evolutionary diversity within Blarinellini is likely underestimated. More broadly, the concordance between phylogeographic structure, divergence history, and long-term climatic stability highlights the dual role of the Hengduan Mountains as both a refuge preserving ancient lineages and a cradle generating new diversity. These findings provide a framework for understanding how geological history, climatic change, and geographic isolation interact to generate biodiversity in mountain hotspots and highlight the potential for substantial cryptic diversity within montane small mammals.
This research was funded by the Second Tibetan Plateau Scientific Expedition and Research (STEP) Program (2024QZKK0200) and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (32570523).
Figures S1–S10
Data type: .docx
Explanation notes: Figure S1. Phylogenetic trees of Blarinellini reconstructed from the combined mitochondrial and nuclear dataset. Left: Bayesian inference (BI) tree with posterior probabilities shown at nodes. — Figure S2. Phylogenetic trees of Blarinellini reconstructed from the concatenated mitochondrial dataset (cyt b + 16S rRNA). — Figure S3. Phylogenetic trees of Blarinellini reconstructed from the concatenated nuclear dataset (ApoB + BRCA1 + RAG2). — Figure S4. Phylogenetic trees of Blarinellini reconstructed from the mitochondrial cyt b gene. Left: Bayesian inference (BI) tree with posterior probabilities shown at nodes. — Figure S5. Phylogenetic trees of Blarinellini reconstructed from the mitochondrial 16S rRNA gene. Left: Bayesian inference (BI) tree with posterior probabilities shown at nodes. — Figure S6. Phylogenetic trees of Blarinellini reconstructed from the nuclear ApoB gene. — Figure S7. Phylogenetic trees of Blarinellini reconstructed from the nuclear RAG2 gene. — Figure S8. Phylogenetic trees of Blarinellini reconstructed from the nuclear BRCA1 gene. — Figure S9. Median-joining network of ApoB haplotypes in Blarinellini. Circle size is proportional to haplotype frequency. — Figure S10. Mismatch distribution analyses for each subclade of Blarinella quadraticauda and B. wardi based on ApoB sequence data.
Tables S1–S8
Data type: .xlsx
Explanation notes: Table SS1. Sample information, voucher specimens, and GenBank accession numbers for the Blarinellini specimens used in this study. — Table SS2. Partition schemes and substitution models selected for divergence time estimation in BEAST2. — Table S3. Percent contribution of the bioclimatic variables used in the final MaxEnt ecological niche models for B. quadraticauda and B. wardi. — Table S4. Optimal MaxEnt model settings for B. quadraticauda and B. wardi. — Table S5. Population genetic parameters based on ApoB sequences for subclades within Blarinellini. — Table S6. Analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA) based on ApoB sequences for populations. — Table S7. Pairwise FST (below diagonal) and genetic distance (p distance; above diagonal) based on cyt b sequence data for Blarinellini populations. — Table S8. Pairwise FST (below diagonal) and genetic distance (p distance; above diagonal) based on ApoB sequence data for Blarinellini populations.