Research Article |
Academic editor: Ingmar Werneburg
© 2022 Irina Ruf.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Ruf I (2022) The turbinal skeleton of Pentalagus furnessi (Leporidae, Lagomorpha). Vertebrate Zoology 72: 423-432. https://doi.org/10.3897/vz.72.e83324
|
The turbinal skeleton inside the nasal cavity supports the respiratory and olfactory epithelia of the mammalian nose and can provide systematic and morphofunctional information. For the first time, the turbinal skeleton of Pentalagus furnessi (Amami rabbit) from Japan is described based on µCT scans and virtual 3D reconstructions of two specimens. In general, the turbinal skeleton of Pentalagus furnessi resembles the pattern and characters observed in other Leporidae. The maxilloturbinal is highly dendritic, nasoturbinal and crista semicircularis are in close contact and form a common recess, the frontoturbinal recess houses two frontoturbinals and one interturbinal between them, the ethmoturbinal recess houses three ethmoturbinals and one interturbinal between ethmoturbinal I and II. Pentalagus furnessi is derived from the leporid grundplan in having a lamina semicircularis with almost straight posterior margin and ventral lamella and in showing a single-scrolled and relatively short interturbinal between frontoturbinal 1 and 2. These characters can be regarded as autapomorphic for the Amami rabbit. Furthermore, the two specimens have an additional small and short interturbinal between frontoturbinal 2 and ethmoturbinal I that shows some variation. This pattern supports previous observations of intraspecific variation of certain interturbinals in Oryctolagus cuniculus and some Sylvilagus and Lepus species. The comparison of the turbinal skeleton of Pentalagus furnessi and its possible sister taxon (e.g., Pronolagus, Poelagus or Caprolagus) reveals a puzzling pattern which is discussed.
Amami rabbit, lamina semicircularis, interturbinal, maxilloturbinal, µCT, nasal cavity, olfactory turbinals, respiratory turbinals
Pentalagus furnessi (Amami rabbit) is a medium-sized leporid and the only living species of the genus. Today, Pentalagus furnessi is restricted to Amami Oshima and Tokunoshima (Ryukyu Islands) in southern Japan and probably arrived at the latter during the early Middle Pleistocene. The species is known from only four fragmented extant populations, which in concert with habitat loss and introduction of dogs, cats and Herpestes javanicus accounts for the classification “Endangered” by the IUCN. The Amami rabbit differs from all other living Leporidae in having very short ears, small eyes, tail and hindfeet; the claws are significantly longer and used for digging burrows as well as climbing steep slopes; vocalization is comparable to Ochotona (
As an insular species, Pentalagus furnessi is enigmatic in several respects but still little is known about its cranial anatomy. While some external cranial and dental studies of Pentalagus furnessi exist (e.g.,
The mammalian cranium holds important structural complexes for understanding evolution, development and function of the sensory systems, dietary and locomotory adaptations as well as phylogenetic information (e.g.,
The present study provides the first anatomical description of intracranial structures in Pentalagus furnessi focusing on nasal structures. The turbinal skeleton supports the respiratory and olfactory epithelia and provides phylogenetic as well as morphofunctional information as already demonstrated in several other mammalian orders (e.g.,
This study is based on two adult macerated skulls of Pentalagus furnessi that are housed in the National Museum of Nature and Science, Tokyo, Japan. Specimen M 12939 was scanned with the µCT scanner (Fraunhofer/ProConXray/Feinfocus) housed at the Senckenberg Forschungsinstitut und Naturmuseum Frankfurt, Frankfurt am Main, Germany. Scan parameters are 90 kV, 89 µA, 1500 ms exposure time, 1600 projections, and 0.0252 mm resolution (isotropic voxel size). Specimen M 12940 was scanned at Fraunhofer IIS, Deggendorf, Germany, with a TomoScope HV 500 by Werth Messtechnik GmbH Gießen; scan parameters are 150 kV, 300µA, 666ms exposure time, 1200 projections, and 0.0499 mm resolution (isotropic voxel size). The µCT data were processed with VGStudio MAX 2.2 (Volume Graphics, Heidelberg, Germany) and the virtual 3D model of the turbinal skeleton of M 12940 was manually segmented in Avizo 9.01 (Thermo Fisher Scientific FEI).
Anatomical terminology follows
Lagomorph phylogeny follows
Both studied Pentalagus furnessi specimens are very similar in their turbinal morphology. Thus, the anatomical description mainly refers to specimen M 12940, and specimen M 12939 is mentioned for intraspecific differences.
The nasal cavity of Pentalagus furnessi is large and extends below the endocranial cavity, where the olfactory bulbs are located (Fig.
Virtual 3D model of the rostrum and right turbinal skeleton of Pentalagus furnessi (M 12940) in A right lateral, B dorsal and C ventral view. The dermal bones are transparent and provide insight into the nasal cavity showing the segmented right turbinals. Colour code refers to Fig.
Virtual 3D model of the right turbinal skeleton of Pentalagus furnessi (M 12940) in A medial, B lateral, C dorsal and D ventral view. Abbreviations: al, anterior lamella; et I–III, ethmoturbinal I–III; ft1-2, frontoturbinal 1–2; hs, hiatus semilunaris; it, interturbinal; ls, lamina semicircularis; mt, maxilloturbinal; nt, nasoturbinal; pl, posterior lamella. Scale bar: 10 mm.
The lamina semicircularis is sickle-shaped reflecting the posterior border of the nasoturbinal and forms the anteromedial wall of the pars lateralis as well as of the hiatus semilunaris (Fig.
The pars lateralis of the nasal cavity comprises the frontoturbinal recess (dorsally) and the large maxillary sinus (ventrally) that are separated by the lamina horizontalis but confluent anteriorly (Figs
Transversal µCT images through the nasal cavity of Pentalagus furnessi (M 12940) from anterior (A) to posterior (D). Sections are indicated on the 3D model. Colour code of the right turbinal skeleton refers to Fig.
Transversal µCT images through the nasal cavity of Pentalagus furnessi. A specimen M 12940, B specimen M 12939. Note the differences in topography of the additional interturbinal between frontoturbinal 2 and ethmoturbinal I. In specimen M 12940 anteriorly this interturbinal and frontoturbinal 2 have a common origin and the former runs posteromedially to merge with ethmoturbinal I (A), whereas in specimen M 12939 the additional interturbinal is a very low ridge on the lamina horizontalis (B). Colour code of the right turbinal skeleton refers to Fig.
The pars posterior of the nasal cavity comprises the ethmoturbinal recess and houses three ethmoturbinals and one interturbinal between ethmoturbinal I and II (Fig.
The interturbinal is relatively short and situated in the posterior part of the ethmoturbinal recess where it arises entirely from the lamina horizontalis (Figs
Ethmoturbinal II is the second largest ethmoturbinal (Fig.
Ethmoturbinal III is the most posterior olfactory turbinal and its size is comparable to the interturbinal inside the ethmoturbinal recess (Fig.
Generally, the turbinal skeleton of Pentalagus furnessi resembles the pattern and characters observed in other Leporidae (
In addition, Pentalagus furnessi shows some apomorphic characters in the turbinal skeleton (Fig.
Apomorphic characters of the turbinal skeleton of Lagomorpha mapped on a phylogeny comprising all extant genera based on molecular data (
Comparison of Pentalagus furnessi (M 12940), Poelagus marjorita (28732), Romerolagus diazi (10977), Lepus europaeus (M6335), and Ochotona alpina (100485) based on transversal µCT images through the nasal cavity. A different patterns of the lamina semicircularis; the ventral lamella can be significantly rolled up like in Poleagus and Romerolagus, or straight like in Pentalagus and Ochotona; note the cavity formed by the ventral lamella of Poelagus as indicated by the asterisk (*). B turbinal shape patterns in the frontoturbinal recess; note the different orientation of scrolling of the interturbinal in Pentalagus and Poelagus. Abbreviations: dl, dorsal lamella; et I, ethmoturbinal I; ft1–2, frontoturbinal 1–2; it, interturbinal; ls, lamina semicircularis; mt, maxilloturbinal; vl, ventral lamella. Not to scale.
The two studied specimens of Pentalagus furnessi show some variation in the detailed morphology of certain olfactory turbinals including left-right asymmetry, e.g., the additional interturbinal between frontoturbinal 2 and ethmoturbinal I. Intraspecific variation of smaller interturbinals has already been described in Oryctolagus cuniculus, some Sylvilagus and Lepus species, and in Canis lupus familiaris (
The sister-group relationship of Pentalagus furnessi is still debated and several hypotheses exist. Possible candidates are Pronolagus spp. (eastern and southern Africa), Bunolagus monticularis (South Africa), Poelagus marjorita (The Democratic Republic of the Congo, South Sudan, Sudan, Uganda) and Caprolagus hispidus (Himalayan region of India, Bhutan, Nepal) although morphological similarities with the former may be due to convergent evolution (
The first anatomical description of the turbinal skeleton in Pentalagus furnessi sheds new light on intracranial diversity and cranial variation in Leporidae. The Amami rabbit shows a combination of typical leporid and autapomorphic characters. The latter comprise the relatively short and single-scrolled interturbinal between frontoturbinal 1 and 2 and a straight ventral lamella of the lamina semicircularis. Pentalagus furnessi differs from the turbinal skeleton of possible sister-group species in several respects. This underpins the great variation observed in the lagomorph skull that contradicts the generally assumed conservative morphology of Lagomorpha (e.g.,
Pentalagus furnessi has a heavier and thicker skull than many other leporid species (
This study is dedicated to Wolfgang Maier on the occasion of his 80th birthday. Wolfgang Maier is a renowned expert in the development and comparative morphology of the mammalian nose and many years ago, he introduced me to the fascinating world of mammalian turbinals for which I am deeply grateful.
I thank Shin-ichiro Kawada (Department of Zoology, Division of Vertebrates, National Museum of Nature and Science, Tokyo) for loan of the Pentalagus furnessi specimens. Katrin Krohmann and Thomas Lehmann (Senckenberg Forschungsinstitut und Naturmuseum Frankfurt) supported me with µCT scans as well as data and image processing. Furthermore, I thank the people who gave me access to the specimens used for comparison in the present study: T. Martin (Universität Bonn), D. Möricke (Staatliches Museum für Naturkunde Stuttgart), F. Mayer (Museum für Naturkunde, Berlin), L. Costeur (Naturhistorisches Museum Basel). Scanning of these specimens was funded by the German Research Foundation DFG (RU 1496/4-1). Great thanks go to Thomas Macrini and Quentin Martinez who helped to improve the manuscript.