Research Article |
Corresponding author: Hinrich Kaiser ( chalcopis@yahoo.com ) Academic editor: Uwe Fritz
© 2022 Fred Kraus, Hinrich Kaiser, Mark O’Shea.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Kraus F, Kaiser H, O’Shea M (2022) Hidden diversity in semi-fossorial Melanesian forest snakes: A revision of the Toxicocalamus loriae complex (Squamata, Elapidae) from New Guinea. Vertebrate Zoology 72: 997-1034. https://doi.org/10.3897/vz.72.e89647
|
With its conservative set of scalation characters, Toxicocalamus loriae is a morphologically confusing species to which a wide array of phenotypes has been assigned. Careful analysis of 224 museum specimens reveals that multiple distinct species remain hidden under the name T. loriae and that diagnostic, species-level differences are more nuanced in this group of snakes than among other members of the genus. Our taxonomic reassessment leads us to resurrect the species T. lamingtoni comb. nov., T. loennbergii comb. nov., and T. nymani comb. nov. from synonymy with T. loriae, retain only T. pratti as a synonym, and describe three new species. As a consequence, T. loriae is no longer recognized as ranging throughout the entire island of New Guinea but is instead restricted to the southern versant of the Papuan Peninsula, and T. lamingtoni and T. spilorhynchus sp. nov. are species restricted to that same peninsula’s northern versant. Toxicocalamus loennbergii is known only from the type series taken on the Onin Peninsula in West Papua, Indonesia, Toxicocalamus atratus sp. nov. is a high-elevation (800–2200 m) Central Highlands endemic, and T. vertebralis sp. nov. ranges from the Central Highlands of Papua New Guinea eastward into the Wau area of Morobe Province. Toxicocalamus nymani inhabits a geologically more heterogenous region, occurring from the Central Highlands eastward to the Huon Peninsula, including Karkar Island, and adjacent areas of Madang Province as well as the northernmost reaches of the Papuan Peninsula. We expect that denser geographic sampling across New Guinea and focussed specimen collection of a few known populations will result in the recognition of additional species in this complex.
Biogeography, Hydrophiinae, morphology, new species, New Guinea, snake, taxonomy
Toxicocalamus Boulenger, 1896 is the most speciose genus of terrestrial snakes in Melanesia, with 17 species currently recognized (
Toxicocalamus is a morphologically unusual lineage on account of diverse scale fusions and divisions and differences in body habitus, the combination of which might be used to characterize distinct genera in other snake clades. However, phylogenetic analysis has shown that Toxicocalamus is indeed monophyletic and that McDowell’s recognition of generic or subgeneric divisions would render each of those purported genera or subgenera polyphyletic (
The aforementioned distinctive scale patterns and body morphologies allow ready distinction of many Toxicocalamus species. Among the exceptions are species related to T. loriae (Boulenger, 1898), which were informally called the “T. loriae group” by
The T. loriae Group is not morphologically cohesive, however, because the somewhat divergent T. mintoni Kraus, 2009 and T. pachysomus Kraus, 2009 cluster with members of this group in the molecular analysis, whereas true T. loriae may be more closely related to other species of Toxicocalamus (based on relatively low branch support that could easily be overturned with study of additional loci;
Among Toxicocalamus, the T. loriae Group is rather unusual in being moderately well collected overall, and two of the sampled localities have produced large specimen series that allow for a better assessment of intraspecific morphological variation than for other species in the genus. Nonetheless, the taxonomy of this group has not been addressed in comprehensive fashion since
We examined 224 specimens, including all known specimens of T. “loriae” from all localities where members of this complex have been collected. We made one exception for the largest, single-locality sample for one new species we describe and recognize below as a member of this group (Kundiawa, Chimbu Province, Papua New Guinea; n = 118), of which we included only 21 specimens to avoid overwhelming trends within and between populations represented by far fewer specimens with the sheer quantity of data from a single locality. GPS coordinates for localities use the Australian Geodetic Datum (AGD66), and specimen numbers are listed with institutional abbreviations as follows: American Museum of Natural History, New York, USA (
We measured snout–vent length (SVL) and tail length (TL) to the nearest mm with a plastic ruler on freshly euthanized specimens and by laying a non-elastic string along preserved specimens and measuring the length of string against a tape measure. We acknowledge that measurements of coiled snakes have inherent inaccuracies due to the twisting of specimens (such as dorsiflexion and ventriflexion or sideways coiling instead of regular, dorsoventral coiling), and our measurements may therefore differ from actual measurements by several millimetres. Our main use of these measurements is in the calculation of ratios, which makes potential measurement errors less impactful since numerator and denominator share these errors. We calculated the tail-length ratio (TLR) as TL / (SVL + TL). We found relative snout width to be important in diagnosing some of the species, and we quantified this character by taking the ratio (to two decimal places) of snout length (SNL, measured from the posterior point of the frontal scale to the tip of the snout) to snout width (SNW, measured across the head at the anterior margin of the eyes) from photographs of each specimen. We found relative eye diameter to be useful for discriminating among these same species, and we quantified that character by taking the ratio (to two decimal places) of eye diameter (EY) to SNL. We also used the subcaudal ratio (SCR, the number of subcaudal scales divided by the number of ventral + subcaudal scales;
Diagnostic features and comparisons to other species are based on our own data as well as those from
During the final preparations of our revision of this manuscript, the description of T. longhagen was published by
When applying statistical methods to a group like Toxicocalamus, in which sample sizes are generally small, care must be taken to ensure statistical procedures follow best practices. We therefore report the results of our tests with a suitable degree of confidence (using significance levels of at least p < 0.01) but with the caveat that additional sampling may shift the significance level of inference (
We initially considered comparing the morphology of some T. loriae Group populations on a finer scale based on geography and colouration, and this appeared especially relevant to the diagnosis of populations in the Central Highlands, the Huon Peninsula, the Adelbert Range, and the Wau–Garaina Region of Morobe Province in Papua New Guinea. However, due to the small sample sizes for some of these localities, we could not use an analysis of variance at this stage and worked instead using t-tests in pairwise sample comparisons. When no statistically significant differences could be identified between samples in one or more of these comparisons, we combined those samples and conducted successively more inclusive comparisons until only samples with significant differences remained. We then tested the hypotheses represented by these operational taxonomic units (OTUs) against morphological characteristics to reach well-founded taxonomic decisions. Values for the results of our t-tests include the t-values with subscripted degrees of freedom as well as the p-value. Once species boundaries could be confirmed independently by gross morphological characteristics and tests of basic measurements, we conducted an ANOVA, with post-hoc Tukey pairwise comparisons.
The outcome of our Kolmogorov-Smirnov and Levene’s Tests showed that the T. loriae Group populations for which more than five specimens were available showed no significant difference from what would be expected in normally distributed populations and there was no indication of heteroscedasticity. We extrapolated these findings to propose that smaller samples were also derived from normally distributed, homoscedastic populations, and we used t-tests with the caveat that additional samples of smaller populations may indeed shift the statistical inference for those comparisons. However, in a testament to the distinctiveness of these groups, levels of significance in analyses with p << 0.01 would most likely remain significant at p < 0.01 even if sample sizes were expanded. Based on maximum female size there appear to be three divisions in body size among members of the T. loriae Group, which we consider modest (maximum female SVL < 575 mm), moderate (SVL between 575 and 650 mm), and large (SVL > 650 mm). Furthermore, as with all species of Toxicocalamus, members of the T. loriae Group display a strong, statistically highly significant (p < 0.00001 for six tested OTUs; n = 90 females, 105 males) sexual dimorphism in the number of subcaudal scales, with females invariably possessing a much lower number of subcaudals than males (nearly 40% fewer on average in the data set for the species discussed herein). The ANOVA confirmed that the variation in ventral and subcaudal scales between the analysed OTUs identified significant differences, all at p < 0.00001 (ventral scales in males: f = 58.5312; ventral scales in females: f = 24.6121; subcaudal scales in males: f = 8.8254; subcaudal scales in females: f = 9.3021). A summary of several relevant characteristics is provided in Table
Basic statistics for certain length and scale characteristics of Toxicocalamus loriae Group species discussed herein.
Character | Sex | Taxon | ||||||
atratus sp. nov. | lamingtoni | loennbergi | loriae | nymani | spilorhynchus sp. nov. | vertebralis sp. nov. | ||
n | 43♀, 49♂ | 9♀, 9♂ | 4♀ | 4♀, 15♂ | 21♀, 18♂ | 6♀, 8♂ | 10♀, 9♂ | |
Maximum known length (mm) SVL + TL = TTL | ♀ | 682 + 49 731 | 500 + 57 = 557 | 565 + 55 = 620 | 440 + 93 = 533 | 540 + 68 = 608 | 600 + 67 = 667 | 685 + 82 = 767 |
♂ | 655 + 117 = 772 | 420 + 110 = 530 | none | 490 + 90 + = 580 | 422 + 84 = 506 | 332 + 79 = 411 | 565 + 103 = 668 | |
TL R, mean ± SD (Range) | ♀ | 9.9 ± 1.7 (6.7–14.9) | 10.3 ± 0.9 (9.0–11.6) | 10.2 ± 0.9 (8.9–11.2) | 14.1 ± 3.3 (10.8–17.5) | 10.5 ± 1.0 (9.2–12.9) | 9.6 ± 0.6 (8.9–10.2) | 9.4 ± 1.4 (6.5–10.7) |
♂ | 15.6 ± 1.7 (12.9–19.4) | 18.8 ± 1.4 (16.7–20.8) | none | 16.6 ± 1.7 (13.4–19.1) | 16.1 ± 1.3 (13.3–17.9) | 18.4 ± 0.5 (17.9–19.2) | 14.7 ± 1.3 (13.3–17.1) | |
Ventrals, mean ± SD (Range) | ♀ | 206 ± 7 (187–218) | 190 ± 3 (186–195) | 216 ± 2 (214–220) | 179 ± 7 (175–190) | 198 ± 5 (191–210) | 190 ± 7 (178–197) | 218 ± 9 (203–232) |
♂ | 196 ± 5 (177–206) | 170 ± 5 (160–178) | none | 184 ± 10 (162–197) | 187 ± 7 (178–198) | 178 ± 4 (172–184) | 201 ± 5 (194–210) | |
Subcaudals, mean ± SD (Range) | ♀ | 31 ± 3 (26–41) | 29 ± 2 (26–34) | 28 ± 3 (23–32) | 31 ± 2 (28–33) | 30 ± 3 (26–37) | 26 ± 3 (20–29) | 35 ± 2 (31–38) |
♂ | 44 ± 2 (40–47) | 46 ± 4 (41–53) | none | 44 ± 3 (40–50) | 44 ± 2 (39–48) | 51 ± 4 (43–57) | 45 ± 4 (39–52) | |
SCR, mean ± SD (Range) | ♀ | 12.9 ± 1.3 (11.2–17.8) | 13.2 ± 0.8 (12.2–14.9) | 11.3 ± 1.1 (9.7–12.7) | 14.6 ± 1.0 (13.5–16.1) | 13.1 ± 1.1 (11.6–15.8) | 11.9 ± 1.1 (10.0–13.1) | 13.7 ± 0.7 (12.8–14.8) |
♂ | 18.3 ± 0.8 (16.9–21.0) | 21.4 ± 1.2 (19.3–23.0) | none | 19.4 ± 1.4 (17.1–21.5) | 19.1 ± 0.9 (17.5–20.7) | 22.1 ± 1.2 (20.0–24.0) | 18.4 ± 1.0 (16.7–20.5) |
Intergenials. The posterior genials may be separated by one or two intergenials. Presence of two intergenials invariably results in the complete separation of the posterior genials, but when only a single intergenial is present anterior contact between the posterior genials may or may not occur and can extend for up to half their length. In the sole species characterized by two intergenials (T. loriae), these occur one behind the other with the widest point of each scale at its anterior end. The three new species described below predominantly possess a single intergenial, but specimens may rarely have two intergenials in a slightly anomalous arrangement, which may include (1) side-by-side instead of midline positioning, or (2) the presence of a tiny intercalary scale at the anterior end of a normal-sized intergenial. In all species with single intergenials, their widest portion is usually at the posterior end but may occasionally occur at the centre or, in very few specimens, at the anterior portion of the scale.
Vent covering. The vent is covered by a single scale in one species (T. lamingtoni) and by two scales in all others. The traditional way of handling this character in snake taxonomy has been to misname this covering as the “anal scale” (anus = opening for solid waste excretion, vent = cloacal opening for urinary, faecal, and reproductive excretion) and/or to use the character state “single” for a covering made up by one scale and “divided” when two scales are present. Describing a scale as “divided” implies a process: at some point the scale was whole. The development of scales begins with “nuclei” of scale formation (i.e., tissue sections before there is a scale;
Contact between preocular and nasal. In most species of this group the preocular and nasal are in contact with each other. The recently described T. mattisoni is characterized by lacking this contact due to intervening contact between the prefrontal and second supralabial. Most species considered herein show rare variation in this feature, though they usually exhibit contact between preocular and nasal. In cases where the prefrontal does contact the second supralabial, it is usually only a point contact and rarely exhibits the broad contact between those scales seen in T. mattisoni.
Postoculars. The number of postoculars can be one or two and shows no variation in some species. In others, this character may vary intraspecifically but within such variation manifests strong tendencies (> 90%) to favour one state over the other.
Posterior temporals. The number of posterior temporals (scales between the parietals and supralabials that are not also in contact with the postoculars) varies between one and five, but the vast majority of specimens have two (55.5%) or three (43.2%). One specimen has a single posterior temporal on one side (two on the other), three specimens have four on one side (three on the other), and one specimen has five on one side (three on the other). Some species show no variation in temporal number, but usually there is intraspecific variation though showing a strong central tendency toward either two or three posterior temporals. Specimens with one, four, or five temporals invariably have two or three on the other side, which indicates that posterior temporal combinations other than two or three are aberrations.
Ventral colour pattern. Ventral colour pattern is a key distinguishing feature for species in this complex. In adults, venters are uniformly pale yellow in four species, yellow with or without a central row of brown spots or bars in another species, and black in two. Species with black venters (brown in preservative) may have the posterior area of each ventral scale appear paler than its anterior area, creating a banded appearance. This banding becomes more pronounced in specimens after an extended time in preservative, presumably due to melanin degradation in ethanol or via light exposure, with melanin apparently lost first in the thinner tissues along the posterior end of each scale. For some specimens, this feature may become difficult to observe when severe bleaching has occurred, in which case it is also difficult to determine whether a yellowish or pale-brown venter was the natural state for a particular specimen or an artifact of preservation. It is often possible to infer the natural state by consulting the dorsal side, where an unnaturally pale colour would indicate that bleaching has occurred. Furthermore, in one black-ventered species, small juveniles have a uniformly yellow venter that soon becomes clouded with melanin as the animal grows; in the second black-ventered species, the venter is black throughout life. All other species for which information is available have yellow venters as juveniles.
Juvenile head pattern. Members of the T. loriae Group are well known for having yellow markings on the nape and often on the head. The exact patterning of these pale elements on the heads of juveniles and their ontogenetic change is diagnostic for several of the species of this group. Of specific diagnostic utility are the completeness and width of the pale nuchal collar and the presence of pale blotches on the prefrontals.
Tail spine. The tail spine is usually paler than the remainder of the tail in most species but is uniformly dark in others.
Apistocalamus loriae Boulenger, 1898: 705.
Apistocalamus Pratti Boulenger, 1904: 451.
Apisthocalamus loriae – Boulenger, 1908: 249.
Apisthocalamus pratti – Boulenger, 1908: 249.
Apisthocalamus prattii – Barbour, 1912: 201.
Apistocalamus pratti – McDowell, 1967: 537.
Toxicocalamus (Apistocalamus) loriae – McDowell, 1969: 455.
Toxicocalamus loriae
Clade 1 –
Named by
A modestly sized member of the T. loriae Group (maximum SVL in males 490 mm, in females 440 mm) with the following unique combination of characters: two scales covering vent; three infralabials contacting anterior genial; posterior genials separated by two intergenials, one in front of the other; intergenials widest anteriorly. Elongate preocular, at least twice as long as wide, contacting nasal but not internasal; one (in 58% of specimens) or two (42%) postoculars; two (55%) or three (45%) posterior temporals; ventral scale count not sexually dimorphic, 162–197 ventrals in 15 males, 172–190 in four females; subcaudal scale count sexually dimorphic without overlap, 40–50 in males, 28–33 in females; SCR 17.1–21.5% in males, 12.5–16.1% in females; pale markings on prefrontals absent (67%), small or vaguely developed (28%), or present (5%), not obviously correlated with body size; tail spine white, paler than the rest of the tail; venter uniformly yellow, yellow with a mid-ventral row of brown spots on each ventral, with a few brown spots scattered down the venter, or with each spot expanded into a brown bar across the anterior of each ventral.
Toxicocalamus loriae is distinguished from all other members of the T. loriae Group in having the posterior genials separated by two intergenials that are aligned in the midline, one in front of the other, with each scale widest anteriorly. All other species are characterized by having the posterior genials separated by only a single intergenial that is widest posteriorly (typically) or centrally (occasionally). As noted above, in the other species there will rarely be two (or three in
An adult male, with tongue extending from right side of mouth; 490 mm SVL, tail tip missing but TL > 90 mm. Rostral, internasals, and anterior portions of nasals crossed by series of linear impressions, as if the snout had been pressed against a screen during preservation. Rostral wider than tall, notched ventromedially; internasals angulate, semi-triangular, wider than long. Prefrontals distinct from preoculars, approximately square but angled laterally and posteriorly, slightly longer than wide (Fig.
Dorsal views of heads of Toxicocalamus loriae Group snakes, presented as both photographic and line-drawing illustrations. A, A’ holotype of T. loriae (
Right and left lateral views of heads of Toxicocalamus loriae Group snakes, presented as both photographic and line-drawing illustrations. A, A’, B, B’ holotype of T. loriae (
Ventral views of heads of Toxicocalamus loriae Group snakes, presented as both photographic and line-drawing illustrations. A, A’ holotype of T. loriae (
Dorsal scales smooth, not notched posteriorly, without apical pits, in 15-15-15 rows; ventrals 189, each approximately four times as wide as long, tail tip incomplete; two scales covering vent; subcaudals 44+, paired.
In preservative (122 years after collection), dorsum uniformly medium brown; venter yellow with a mid-ventral row of brown spots. Supralabials pale yellow ventrally, suffused with brown on upper portions of Supralabials 2–5 and on posterior portion of Supralabial 6; small amount of yellow colouration also present on the lower parts of the nasals. Chin and throat yellow, with small area of brown suffusion on posterior portions of infralabials, genials, intergenials, and gulars. Iris black.
The anterior margin of the frontal may be almost straight but usually extends slightly forward of the rest of the scale in the midline of the head. The nasals usually have a distinct groove above and below the posterior margin of each naris; a sample from Mt. Obree has either very shallow grooves or lacks them entirely. One (58%) or two (42%) postoculars, both smaller than or occupying approximately the same area as an eye; two (55%) or three (45%) posterior temporals, positioned either as one larger scale above a smaller one, or with the smallest of three scales positioned anterior to the other two, followed posteriorly by a larger upper and a smaller lower temporal; in either configuration, the lowest temporal scale is abutting the posterodorsal margin of the sixth supralabial. Six (97.4%) or seven (2.6%) supralabials, the third and fourth (97.4%) or the third to fifth (2.6%) supralabials contacting eye; five (2.6%) or six (97.4%) infralabials, the first three (22%) or four (78%) in contact with the anterior genial. The anterior genials are wider than the posterior genials and approximately the same length or slightly longer; anterior genials in broad medial contact except in
Dorsal scales invariably in 15-15-15 rows. Ventrals not sexually dimorphic (t14 = –0.2688, p = 0.3958), 162–197 (184 ± 10) in 15 males, 172–190 (179 ± 7) in four females; subcaudals sexually dimorphic without overlap, 40–50 in males, 28–33 in females; SCR sexually dimorphic without overlap, 17.1–21.5% (19.4 ± 1.4%) in males, 12.5–16.1% (14.6 ± 1.0%) in females. Tail tipped by a blunt to pointed conical spine. Maximum SVL 490 mm in males and 440 mm in females, adult TLR = 13.4–19.1% (16.6 ± 1.7%) and 10.8–17.5% (14.1 ± 3.3%), in males and females, respectively. The current dataset, with only two adult females, indicates that there is no statistically significant male-female difference in SVL (t = 0.3034, p = 0.3832). TLR in the two juvenile males (
In preservative, the dorsal colouration is uniformly medium brown (84%) or dark brown (11%) except that one specimen (
Dorsal and right lateral views of heads of juveniles of Toxicocalamus loriae Group snakes. A, B T. loriae (
In life, field notes described
Known almost exclusively from the southern versant of the Owen Stanley Range of Papua New Guinea, from Tapini, Central Province, in the north to Mt. Dayman, Milne Bay Province, in the south, at elevations from 620–1530 m (Fig.
Type localities (stars) and other collection sites (circles) of Toxicocalamus loriae Group species. A Map of New Guinea and its satellite islands, showing the positions of the inset maps and the type locality of T. mintoni (magenta), an endemic of Sudest Island, Milne Bay Province, PNG. Scale = 500 km. B Papua New Guinea and adjacent areas of West New Guinea, Indonesia, with white lines demarcating provincial boundaries. Scale = 250 km. C West Papua Province, Indonesia (WP), showing the type locality of T. loennbergii comb. nov. (orange). Other species treated in this report are T. loriae (dark blue), T. lamingtoni comb. nov. (yellow), T. spilorhynchus sp. nov. (red), T. nymani comb. nov. (neon green), T. vertebralis sp. nov. (pink), and T. atratus sp. nov. (light blue). Additional related species in the T. loriae clade are T. goodenoughensis (brown), T. mattisoni (violet), T. nigrescens (black), T. pachysomus (dark green), and T. “loriae” Clade 4 (white). The type locality of the recently described dubious taxon T. longhagen (tan) is also indicated. Scale = 250 km. Provinces of PNG are Central (Ce), Chimbu (Ch; also spelled Simbu), Gulf (Gu), Hela (He; created in 2012), Eastern Highlands (EH), East Sepik (ES), Enga (En), Jiwaka (Ji; created in 2012), Madang (Ma), Milne Bay (MB), Morobe (Mo), National Capital District (NCD), Oro (Or; also known as Northern Province); Sandaun (Sa; formerly West Sepik), Southern Highlands (SH), Western (We), and Western Highlands (WH). Provinces of West New Guinea are Highland Papua (HP; created in 2022), Papua (Pa), and South Papua (SP; created in 2022). Sites of sympatry are Wau (W; neon green + pink) with two species and Garaina (G; neon green + red + yellow) with three species.
Three individuals from Mt. Obree (elevation ca. 880 m) were obtained from local villagers, who presumably discovered the snakes while gardening. One specimen came from near a stream in primary rainforest (1570 m), and one more was found on the forest floor in primary rainforest on a ridge top (1680 m). At the time of collection, the understory on this ridge was not dense and contained a thick duff layer with a tight root network at the surface; the canopy was 25–30 m above the forest floor, with large emergent araucarians (Araucaria sp., Araucariaceae) reaching heights of 50 m. Farther downslope, near the stream, the forest had a much denser understory. These specimens were found active on the forest floor at 12:00 h and in mid-afternoon (~16:00 h), respectively.
We retain Apistocalamus pratti (
Toxicocalamus loriae is unique among members of the T. loriae Group in having the posterior genials completely separated from contact with each other by two intervening intergenials aligned in the midline of the chin. This character state is among the more distinctive features that diagnose any of the T. loriae Group species. Furthermore, this feature occurs in only a small, contiguous portion of the entire geographical range occupied by the group. In our view, it provides compelling evidence for the unity of this species. However, we note that the sample size for this species is small (n = 19) and almost one-third of those specimens come from a single area (on the NW slope of Mt. Obree); all other localities are represented by only 1–3 specimens. Consequently, it is difficult to assess the importance of some of the morphological and geographic variation seen in this sample. We here consider four points in question that deserve further assessment once sufficiently large specimen series become available.
This character is variable. Three specimens (
Male ventral counts in our sample cover an unusually wide range (162–197) and might be thought to possibly reflect the presence of more than one species in our sample. However, these values seem to vary geographically, with two of the three highest counts (193, 194, 197) seen in the two northernmost samples (Fane, Mafulu) and the two lowest counts in the southernmost samples from Agaun, Milne Bay Province (162) and nearby Mt. Obree (169). Furthermore, the six males from Mt. Obree, Central Province, themselves show a range of variation (169–189) that encompasses 55% of the total variation seen in the entire sample of T. loriae, suggesting that considerable variation in male ventral counts does indeed characterize this species and may not in itself be evidence of multiple species. This interpretation could possibly change when larger sample sizes become available, but the overlap in counts seen in the Agaun and Mt. Obree samples, coupled with the broad variation seen in the latter, makes this seem unlikely.
The large majority of specimens was collected on the southern versant of the central Owen Stanley Range. However, one specimen (
Two specimens (
Pseudapistocalamus Nymani Lönnberg, 1900: 578.
Pseudapisthocalamus nymani – Boulenger, 1908: 249.
Pseudapistocalamus nymani – de Rooij, 1917: 263.
Pseudapistocalamus nymanni – Klemmer, 1963: 328.
Apistocalamus pratti (part) – McDowell, 1967: 537.
Toxicocalamus (Apistocalamus) loriae (part) – McDowell, 1969: 456.
The Swedish zoologist Einar Lönnberg (1865–1942) described this species on the basis of three specimens from Sattelberg, German New Guinea, at the eastern end of the Huon Peninsula (now in Morobe Province, PNG). These were collected by the Swedish botanist Erik Nyman (1866–1900), who visited the area from June–November 1899 (
The species was named for Erik Nyman, the collector of the type series. It also serves as a tribute to a remarkable scientist, who died in 1900 on the journey home to Europe. The description was published in English.
A modestly sized member of the T. loriae Group (maximum SVL in males 422 mm, in females 540 mm) with the following unique combination of characters: two scales covering vent; three infralabials contacting anterior genial; posterior genials entirely separated (45%) by a single intergenial or in anterior (53%) or entire (2%) contact with each other; intergenial usually widest posteriorly or centrally. Preocular approximately as long as wide and never twice as long as wide, usually contacting nasal (94%), not contacting internasal; one (4%) or two (96%) postoculars; one (1%), two (69%), three (27%), four (1%), or five (1%) posterior temporals; 178–198 ventrals in 18 males, 191–210 in 22 females, sexually dimorphic with overlap (t37 = 4.9581, p < 0.00001); 39–48 subcaudals in males, 26–37 in females, sexually dimorphic without overlap; SCR 17.5–20.7% in males, 11.6–15.8% in females, sexually dimorphic without overlap; yellow nuchal collar and yellow markings on prefrontals absent (48%), small or vaguely developed (7%), or present (45%); tail spine paler than remainder of tail; venter uniformly dark brown or dark brown with the posterior of each ventral paler brown or yellowish brown, giving a banded appearance (reported as “blackish brown, edged with light grey” within one year of preservation;
Toxicocalamus nymani is distinguished from T. loriae in having a single intergenial (two in T. loriae) that is widest posteriorly or centrally (widest anteriorly in T. loriae), by its short, squarish preocular (elongate, more than twice as long as high, in T. loriae), and by its dark brown or black venter (yellow with or without mid-ventral series of brown spots in T. loriae); from T. nigrescens by its smaller size (maximum SVL = 540 mm vs. 635 mm in T. nigrescens), short preocular (elongate, more than three times as long as high, in T. nigrescens), and in having two postoculars (one in T. nigrescens) and a dark brown or black venter (grey in T. nigrescens); and from T. mattisoni in having the prefrontal usually (93%) excluded from contacting the second supralabial (prefrontal and second supralabial in contact in T. mattisoni), short preocular (elongate, more than twice as long as high, in T. mattisoni), and in having two postoculars (one in T. mattisoni) and a dark brown or black venter (yellow or pale grey with grey bands across each ventral in T. mattisoni).
An adult female, 435 mm SVL + 42 mm TL = 477 mm TTL. Rostral wider than tall, notched ventromedially; internasals angulate, semi-triangular, wider than long. Prefrontals distinct from preoculars, approximately square but angled posteriorly, slightly longer than wide (Fig.
Dorsal scales smooth, not notched posteriorly, without apical pits, in 15-15-15 rows; ventrals 202, each approximately four times as wide as long; two scales covering vent; subcaudals 28, paired. Tail tipped by a pointed conical spine.
In preservative (114 years after collection), dorsum dark brown dorsally, paler laterally, with brown centre of each scale becoming paler yellow brown at posterior edges. Each ventral scale, including subcaudals, dark brown with paler yellow brown along posterior edges, imparting an overall impression of a dark venter banded with dark brown. Supralabials and rostral largely yellow, all with dark-brown upper margins. Head dark brown with large yellow blotch on each prefrontal and small yellow blotch in anterior part of each preocular. Incomplete yellow nuchal collar, interrupted mid-dorsally by three rows of brown dorsal scales. Chin and throat pale yellow, suffused with brown on mental and anterior portions of anterior gulars and first five infralabials. Tail spine brown, paler than remainder of dorsum. Iris black.
Preoculars are not in contact with the nasals in three specimens from Madang Province (
Dorsal scales invariably in 15-15-15 rows. Ventrals 178–198 (187 ± 7) in 18 males, 191–210 (198 ± 5) in 21 females; subcaudals 39–48 (44 ± 2) in 18 males, 26–37 (30 ± 3) in 20 females; SCR 17.5–20.7% (19.1 ± 0.9%) in males, 11.6–15.8% (13.1 ± 1.1%) in females. Tail tipped by a blunt to pointed conical spine. Maximum SVL in males 422 mm, 540 mm in females, not sexually dimorphic (t31 = –1.4431, p = 0.0795); TLR sexually dimorphic without overlap, in males 13.3–17.9% (16.1 ± 1.3%), in females 9.2–12.9% (10.5 ± 1.0%).
Variation in head colouration is largely geographical, with yellow-spotted heads largely confined to the Huon Peninsula; the specimen from Garaina (
Known from the Huon Peninsula, Morobe Province, to Karkar Island, Madang Province, in northeastern PNG to the general vicinity of Wau and Garaina in the northern Owen Stanley Range at elevations from 120–1470 m (Fig.
We have no particular ecological information for this species but assume its habits are similar to the other species in this complex based on similar morphology and ecological conservatism in the genus.
Subsequent to the original description of T. nymani, the German anthropologist and scientific photographer Richard Gustav Neuhauss (1855–1915) collected an additional six specimens at Lialun – 50 km NNW of Sattelberg along the coast – that were shipped to the ZMB as part of three consignments between July 1909 and August 1910. Only the first shipment was large enough to contain these six specimens, so they must have been collected during 1909. These specimens were briefly listed by
These six Lialun specimens are now catalogued as ZMB 24343–44, 78770–71, and
This species is unusual within the T. loriae Group for the presence of a distinct head colour-pattern dimorphism, with the heads of most adults from the Huon Peninsula boldly spotted with yellow in both juveniles and adults, whereas a few specimens from the Huon Peninsula and all specimens from other localities have uniformly dark heads as adults and only sparse spotting in some juveniles. Given our observations in other T. loriae Group species, we would expect these variants to represent different species, but we have found no other characters that support such a conclusion. Both morphotypes appear sympatric in at least one location (Masba Creek, Morobe Province), and although the microhabitat of these collection sites differed by 60 m in elevation, we do not consider this to be meaningful. Nonetheless, our hypothesis of conspecificity should be tested with molecular and updated morphological data when additional specimens of both forms become available.
Apisthocalamus loennbergii Boulenger, 1908: 248.
Apistocalamus loennbergi – Sternfeld, 1913: 387.
Apistocalamus lönnbergi – de Rooij, 1917: 260.
Apistocalamus loriae (part) – McDowell, 1967: 537.
Toxicocalamus (Apistocalamus) loriae (part) – McDowell, 1969: 456.
As reported by
Because
Named by
A modestly sized member of the T. loriae Group (maximum SVL 565 mm, only females known) with the following unique combination of characters: two scales covering vent; four infralabials contacting anterior genial; a single intergenial separating posterior genials, widest posteriorly. Preocular elongate, approximately twice as long as wide, contacting nasal (62%) or not (38%), not contacting internasal; relatively short snout (SNL/SNW x̄ = 0.95, range = 0.93–0.99); relatively small eye (EY/SNL x̄ = 0.16, range = 0.15–0.18); one postocular (fused to supraocular on one side of one specimen); three posterior temporals; 214–220 ventrals in four females; 23–32 subcaudals; SCR 9.7–12.7%; dark vertebral stripe; large pale blotch on parietal; pale markings on prefrontals absent (50%), small or vaguely developed (25%), or well developed (25%), best developed in the smallest specimen; tail spine white, paler than remainder of tail; and venter uniformly yellow.
Toxicocalamus loennbergii can be distinguished from all other members of the T. loriae Group except some T. loriae and juvenile T. nymani by its uniformly yellow venter. It can be distinguished from T. loriae in having only a single intergenial (two in T. loriae) and from juvenile T. nymani by having four infralabials in contact with the anterior genial (three in 87.5% of T. nymani), a single postocular (usually two in T. nymani), and a dark vertebral stripe (absent in T. nymani). It can further be distinguished from T. nigrescens by its greater number of ventrals (214–220 vs. 184–193 in female T. nigrescens), and dark vertebral stripe (absent in T. nigrescens); and from T. mattisoni in having the preocular contact the nasal (separated by prefrontal contact with the second supralabial in T. mattisoni), its greater number of ventrals (214–220 vs. 170–181 in female T. mattisoni), and dark vertebral stripe (absent in T. mattisoni).
An adult female, 565 mm SVL + 55 mm TL = 620 mm TTL. Rostral wider than tall, notched ventromedially; internasals angulate, semi-triangular, wider than long. Prefrontals distinct from preoculars, approximately square, rounded posterolaterally, bordered below by preocular and nasal, in point contact with second supralabial on right side; preoculars elongate, narrower anteriorly, approximately twice as long as tall (Fig.
Dorsal scales smooth, not notched posteriorly, without apical pits, in 15-15-15 rows; Ventrals 214, each approximately four times wider than long; two scales covering vent; subcaudals 23, paired. Tail tipped by a blunt conical spine.
In preservative (108 years after collection), dorsum reddish brown, darker mid-dorsally, with darker-brown vertebral stripe one scale wide; each dorsal scale with darker brown edges, imparting a reticulated appearance to dorsum, especially laterally. Venter uniformly pale yellow; subcaudals lightly edged in brown at their medial junctures. Supralabials pale yellow ventrally, suffused with brown dorsally. Top of head with vague traces of yellow blotches on parietals and anterior temporals; no pale nuchal collar. Chin and throat pale yellow, with small amount of brown suffusion on mental, sutures between infralabials, and anterior suture of anterior genial. Tail spine brown above and white below. Iris black.
All specimens are female. Prefrontals are bordered below by the preocular and the nasal, but they are in point contact with the second supralabial on one side in two specimens; preoculars are bordered below by the second and third supralabials, except by only the third supralabial on the right side of
Dorsal scales invariably in 15-15-15 rows. Ventrals 214–220 (216 ± 2); subcaudals 23–32 (28 ± 3); SCR 9.7–12.7% (11.3 ± 1.1%). Tail tipped by a blunt to pointed conical spine. Maximum SVL 565 mm, TLR 8.9–11.2% (10.2 ± 0.9%).
In preservative, all specimens are coloured as the holotype dorsally and ventrally. Subcaudals are lightly edged in brown at their medial junctures but dusted with brown posteriorly in
Known only from the type locality, north of Fakfak town on the Onin Peninsula, West Papua Province, Indonesia, at an elevation of 520 m (Fig.
Apisthocalamus lamingtoni Kinghorn, 1928: 290.
Apistocalamus lamingtoni – Roux, 1934: 79.
Toxicocalamus (Apistocalamus) loriae (part) – McDowell, 1969: 456.
Toxicocalamus loriae X T. stanleyanus (part) – McDowell, 1969: 485.
Toxicocalamus loriae
Clade 3 –
The specimens on which
A modestly sized member of the T. loriae Group (male SVL up to 428 mm, female SVL up to 500 mm), with the following unique combination of characters: cloacal plate single; a single intergenial separating posterior genials, widest posteriorly. Preocular elongate, approximately twice as long as high, contacting nasal but not internasal; one postocular; two (92%) or three (8%) posterior temporals; 160–178 ventrals in nine males, 186–195 in nine females, sexually dimorphic without overlap; 41–53 subcaudals in males, 26–34 in females, sexually dimorphic without overlap; SCR 19.3–23.0% in males, 12.2–14.9% in females, sexually dimorphic without overlap; females with very short tails relative to males (TLR sexually dimorphic without overlap, 16.7–20.8% in adult males, 9.0–11.6% in adult females); pale markings on prefrontals absent, even in juveniles; tail spine brown, same colour as remainder of tail; venter uniformly yellow; juveniles with brown anterior supralabials; and head pattern in juveniles typically consisting of a complete, broad, pale band across the nape, parietals, temporals, and last two supralabials, with remainder of head anterior to that lacking pale markings.
Toxicocalamus lamingtoni is unique within the T. loriae Group and distinguished from all other members of the genus except T. buergersi, T. cratermontanus, and T. stanleyanus in having a single cloacal plate; from these last three species T. lamingtoni is easily distinguished by having the preocular and prefrontal distinct (vs. fused). It is further distinguished from T. loriae in having only a single intergenial (vs. two in T. loriae), a dark-brown (vs. white in T. loriae) tail spine, brown anterior supralabials in juveniles (vs. yellow in T. loriae), and the broad yellow nuchal collar in juveniles (vs. narrow and incomplete in T. loriae); from T. nymani by its uniformly yellow venter in adults (vs. black or very dark brown in adult T. nymani), single postocular (usually two in T. nymani), dark-brown (vs. white in T. nymani) tail spine, brown anterior supralabials in juveniles (vs. yellow in T. nymani) , and the broad yellow nuchal collar in juveniles (vs. narrow and incomplete in T. nymani); from T. loennbergii by having two (vs. three in T. loennbergii) posterior temporals, lacking (vs. possessing) a dark vertebral stripe, and having a dark-brown (vs. white in T. loennbergii) tail spine; from T. nigrescens by its smaller size (SVL up to 500 mm in T. lamingtoni and 635 mm in T. nigrescens) and in having a uniformly yellow (vs. grey) venter; and from T. mattisoni in having the preocular contact the nasal (vs. separated by prefrontal contact with the second supralabial in T. mattisoni) and its uniformly yellow venter (vs. pale grey or yellow with grey band in T. mattisoni).
Adult male, 342 mm SVL + 78 mm TL = 420 mm TTL. Rostral broader than high, notched ventromedially; internasals angulate, semi-triangular, wider than long; prefrontals distinct from preoculars, approximately square but angled posteriorly, slightly longer than wide (Fig.
Dorsal scale rows 15-15-15, smooth, not notched posteriorly, without apical pits. Ventrals 173, each approximately four times wider than long; vent covered by single scale; subcaudals 46, paired. Tail tipped by a pointed conical spine.
In preservative (88 years after collection), dorsum uniformly brown-grey, paler laterally. Venter uniformly pale yellow; medial brown markings scattered on several anterior subcaudals, posterior subcaudals largely brown. Anterior five supralabials and rostral uniformly dark brown, last supralabial brown with large yellow blotch. Head otherwise uniformly dark brown. Chin and throat pale yellow suffused with brown on mental, anterior gulars, and first four supralabials. Tail spine brown, not distinct in colour from remainder of tail but slightly paler at tip. Iris black.
Nasals divided by large nares, without grooves above or below naris, though these areas often dimpled or creased. Postoculars one, except two in
Dorsal scale rows invariably 15-15-15. Ventrals 160–178 (170 ± 5) in nine males, 186–195 (190 ± 3) in nine females; subcaudals 41–53 (46 ± 4) in nine males, 26–34 (29 ± 2) in nine females; SCR 19.3–23.0% (21.4 ± 1.2%) in males and 12.2–14.9% (13.2 ± 0.8%) in females. Tail tipped by a blunt to pointed conical spine. Maximum male SVL 428 mm, TLR = 16.7–20.8% (18.8 ± 1.4%); maximum female SVL 500 mm, TL R = 9.0–11.6% (10.3 ± 0.9%).
In preservative, dorsum uniformly grey or brown-grey in recent specimens, fading to uniform medium brown in specimens retained longer in alcohol. Venter uniformly pale yellow; most larger specimens and one neonate have some brown markings on the posterior subcaudals or midventrally on more anterior subcaudals, but these are never densely arrayed. In the Garaina sample, all supralabials and rostral pale yellow ventrally; in samples from south of there supralabials and rostral often densely suffused with brown or grey; in populations from Mt. Lamington and Cape Nelson, anterior 4–5 supralabials and rostral uniform black or dark brown, posterior supralabials mostly yellow. Yellow markings typically absent on nasals and prefrontals, though vaguely developed on prefrontals in two specimens. Nuchal collar evident in specimens < 260 mm SVL but absent or very obscure in specimens > 330 mm SVL, better developed in southern samples; collar narrow in
In life, field notes described
Restricted to the northern versant of the Owen Stanley Mts. in Oro Province and southern Morobe Province, Papua New Guinea, at elevations from 100–940 m (Fig.
Toxicocalamus (Apistocalamus) loriae (part) – McDowell, 1969: 485.
Papua New Guinea: Madang Province: same locality as holotype,
The species epithet is a Latin masculine adjective in recognition of the vertebral stripe that distinguishes this species from most other Toxicocalamus.
A large member of the T. loriae Group (known male SVL up to 565 mm, known female SVL up to 685 mm) with the following unique combination of characters: body length sexually dimorphic (t10 = 2.3826, p = 0.0192); two scales covering vent; three infralabials contacting first genial; a single intergenial between posterior genials, widest posteriorly; preocular contacting nasal (81%) or not (19%), not contacting internasal; relatively long snout (SNL/SNW mean = 1.07, range = 0.95–1.18); relatively large eye (EY/SNL mean = 0.21, range = 0.16–0.28); two postoculars; usually three (74%) posterior temporals; ventral scale count sexually dimorphic with overlap (t17 = 4.7511, p < 0.0001), 194–210 in nine males, 203–232 in nine females and a female embryo; subcaudals 39–52 in males, 31–38 in females, sexually dimorphic without overlap; SCR sexually dimorphic without overlap, 16.7–20.5% in males, 12.8–14.8% in females; adult females with much shorter tails than adult males, TLR 13.3–17.1% in adult males, 6.5–10.7% in adult females; pale parietal blotch absent; pale markings on prefrontals absent (95%) or vague (5%); tail spine white, paler than remainder of tail; and venter uniformly yellow.
Toxicocalamus vertebralis can be distinguished from all other members of the T. loriae Group except T. loennbergii by its dark vertebral line. It is further distinguished from T. mattisoni and T. nigrescens by its greater number of ventrals (198–228 vs. 170–181 and 184–193 in T. mattisoni and T. nigrescens, respectively) and yellow venter (grey or yellow barred with grey in T. mattisoni and T. nigrescens); from T. loriae in having only a single intergenial (vs. two in T. loriae); from juvenile T. nymani by lacking a pale blotch on the prefrontals (vs. present in 80% of T. nymani) and from all T. nymani by significant differences in ventral scale counts for both sexes (males: 194–210 vs. 178–198 in T. nymani, t24 = 5.2049, p = 0.000012; females: 203–232 vs. 182–210 in T. nymani, t30 = 7.3288, p < 0.00001) and subcaudal scale counts in females (31–38 vs. 26–39 in T. nymani, t29 = –3.5633, p = 0.000645); and from T. lamingtoni in having two scales covering the vent (vs. one scale in T. lamingtoni), non-overlapping ventral scale counts in both sexes (males: 194–210 vs. 160–178 in T. lamingtoni; females: 203–232 vs. 189–194 in T. lamingtoni) and subcaudal scale counts in females (31–38 vs. 26–34 in T. lamingtoni; t17 = –4.9232, p = 0.000064), and a white (vs. dark brown in T. lamingtoni) tail spine. The uniformly yellow venter and dark vertebral stripe make T. vertebralis most similar to T. loennbergii, but it can be distinguished from that species in having two postoculars (vs. one in T. loennbergii), a significantly greater number of subcaudals in females (31–38 vs. 23–32 in T. loennbergii; t12 = –4.3818, p = 0.000447), three (vs. four) infralabials contacting the anterior pair of genials, a longer snout (SNL/SNW mean = 1.07, range = 0.95–1.18 vs. 0.95 and 0.93–0.99 in T. loennbergii), larger eye (EY/SNL mean = 0.21, range = 0.16–0.28 vs. 0.16 and 0.15–0.18 in T. loennbergii), and lacking a pale blotch on the parietals (present in T. loennbergii).
Adult female with mid-ventral slit extending through 47 ventrals anterior to vent; 666 mm SVL + 69 mm TL = 735 TTL. Rostral broader than high, notched ventromedially, extending dorsoposteriorly behind nares; internasals angulate, semi-triangular, wider than long (Fig.
Dorsal scale rows 15-15-15, smooth, not notched posteriorly, without apical pits. Ventrals 220, each approximately four times wider than long; two scales covering vent; subcaudals 33, paired. Tail tipped by a pointed conical spine.
In preservative (52 years after collection), dorsum pale brown (Fig.
Ventrals 194–210 (201 ± 5) in nine males and 203–232 (218 ± 9) in ten females; subcaudals 39–52 (45 ± 4) in nine males and 31–38 (35 ± 2) in ten females; SCR 16.7–20.5% (18.4 ± 1.0%) in males, 12.8–14.8% (13.7 ± 0.7%) in females. The lowest male ventral and subcaudal counts are in
Specimens are red brown (Fig.
A photo of
Toxicocalamus loriae Group species in live and perimortem photographs to show colour in life. A, B T. vertebralis sp. nov. (
Known from the Schrader and Bismarck Ranges at the eastern end of the Central Highlands of Papua New Guinea, the vicinity of Wau (Morobe Province), and the Star Mountains near the Indonesian border, at elevations from 1170–1880 m (Fig.
Toxicocalamus loriae X T. stanleyanus (part) – McDowell, 1969: 485.
Toxicocalamus loriae
Clade 2 –
Papua New Guinea: Morobe Province: same locality as holotype,
Papua New Guinea: Morobe Province: Garaina, 7.89°S, 147.14°E, elev. 770 m,
The species epithet is a Latinized masculine adjective formed by combining the Greek σπίλος (spilos, meaning spot) and ῥῠ́γχος (rhynchos, meaning snout), in recognition of the distinctive prefrontal blotch that typifies the species.
A moderately sized member of the T. loriae Group (SVL up to 600 mm) with the following unique combination of characters: two scales covering vent; three infralabials contacting first genial; a single intergenial between posterior genials, widest posteriorly; preocular contacting nasal (87%) or not (13%), not contacting internasal (93.3%); relatively long snout (SNL/SNW mean = 1.16, range = 0.99–1.40); relatively large eye (EY/SNL mean = 0.22, range = 0.17–0.24); two postoculars (93%); usually three (67%) posterior temporals; ventral scale count sexually dimorphic with overlap (t12 = 3.7381, p = 0.001416), 172–184 ventrals in eight males, 178–197 in six females; subcaudals sexually dimorphic without overlap, 43–57 in males, 20–29 in females; SCR strongly sexually dimorphic, with the relative contribution of subcaudal scale number in males twice what it is in females (20.0–24.0 in males, 10.0–13.1 in females); pale parietal blotch usually absent (present in four small specimens); pale markings on prefrontals present; and venter uniformly yellow.
Toxicocalamus spilorhynchus can be distinguished from all other members of the T. loriae Group except T. loennbergii and T. vertebralis by its dark vertebral stripe. It is further distinguished from T. mattisoni, T. nigrescens, and adult T. nymani by its yellow venter (vs. grey, yellow barred with grey, or dark brown in those other species); from T. loriae in having only a single intergenial (vs. two in T. loriae); and from T. lamingtoni in overlapping but significantly different ventral and subcaudal counts in males (ventrals: 172–184 vs. 160–178 in T. lamingtoni, t15 = –3.0499, p = 0.004053; subcaudals: 43–57 vs. 41–53 in T. lamingtoni, t15 = –1.8533, p = 0.041808), by having two scales covering the vent (vs. one scale in T. lamingtoni), and a white (vs. dark-brown in T. lamingtoni) tail spine. It can be distinguished from juvenile T. nymani by details of head patterning: in T. spilorhynchus the pale blotches on the prefrontals are typically fused into a continuous chevron or blotch across the snout (vs. one discrete small spot on each prefrontal in T. nymani), the pale nuchal collar is continuous and includes the posterior portion of the parietals (vs. the band is replaced by a single elongate spot on each side of the nape in T. nymani), and there is often a pale blotch on the anterior temporal and anterolateral portion of the parietal (vs. absent in T. nymani). The yellow venter and dark vertebral stripe make T. vertebralis most similar to T. loennbergii and T. vertebralis. It can be distinguished from T. loennbergii by having two postoculars (vs. one in T. loennbergii), three (vs. four) infralabials contacting the anterior pair of genials, a longer snout (SNL/SNW mean = 1.16, range = 0.99–1.40 vs. 0.95 and 0.93–0.99 in T. loennbergii), larger eye (EY/SNL mean = 0.22, range = 0.17–0.24 vs. 0.16 and 0.15–0.18 in T. loennbergii), and lacking a pale blotch on the parietals (present in T. loennbergii) except in four small specimens. Toxicocalamus spilorhynchus can be distinguished from T. vertebralis by both sexes having significantly fewer ventrals (172–184 in males vs. 194–210 in T. vertebralis, t15 = –10.1025, p < 0.00001; 178–197 in females vs. 203–232 in T. vertebralis, t14 = 6.0435; p < 0.000015) and more subcaudals (43–57 in males vs. 39–52 in T. vertebralis, t15 = 2.4970, p = 0.012326; 20–29 in females vs. 31–38 in T. vertebralis, t14 = –5.8962, p = 0.000019); a pale blotch on each prefrontal (vs. absent in [or vague in one] T. vertebralis); and having the yellow venter become dusted with brown on the anterior of each ventral scale in large adults (vs. uniformly yellow throughout life in T. vertebralis).
Adult female with mid-ventral slit extending through seven ventrals at midbody; 600 mm SVL + 65 mm, TL = 665 mm TTL. Rostral broader than high, notched ventromedially, not extending dorsoposteriorly as far as nares; internasals angulate, semi-triangular, wider than long; prefrontals distinct from preoculars, approximately square, wider anteriorly than posteriorly, angled posterolaterally (Fig.
Dorsal scale rows 14-15-15, smooth, not notched posteriorly, without apical pits; on approximately posterior third of body vertebral scale row and sixth row on right composed of scales larger than adjacent rows. Ventrals 193, each approximately four times wider than long; two scales covering vent; subcaudals 29, paired. Tail tipped by a pointed conical spine.
In preservative (nine years after collection), dorsum pale brown, with poorly defined darker-brown vertebral stripe (Fig.
Ventrals 172–184 (178 ± 4) in eight males and 178–197 (190 ± 7) in six females; subcaudals 43–57 (51 ± 4) in eight males and 20–29 (26 ± 3) in six females. Tails in females are much shorter than in males, both in terms of adult tail length and relative subcaudal number. TLR is 17.9–19.2% (18.4 ± 0.5%) in four adult males and 8.9–10.2% (9.6 ± 0.6%) in two adult females, whereas SCR is 20.0–24.0% (22.1 ± 1.2%) in eight males and 10.0–13.1% (11.9 ± 1.1%) in six females. Numbers of postoculars are two, except on the right side of
Specimens are brown dorsally with a dark-brown vertebral stripe and with each scale narrowly margined in dark brown posteriorly. The first rows of scales in small specimens are yellow, so that the dark-brown margining of each scale imparts the appearance of narrow brown stripes on the lower sides. Venters are uniformly yellow in smaller specimens (153–336 mm SVL) but each scale is clouded with pale brown anteriorly in the only large specimen (the holotype, 600 mm SVL). Juveniles are boldly patterned with yellow blotches on a black ground that typically involves a yellow chevron across the prefrontals, a yellow nuchal collar, and yellow blotches on the parietals and anterior temporals (Fig.
A photo of
Known from the uplands of the Owen Stanley Range from the vicinity of Garaina, Morobe Province, PNG, at elevations from 770–1850 m (Fig.
We refer
Toxicocalamus (Apistocalamus) loriae (part) – McDowell, 1969: 485.
Papua New Guinea: Chimbu Province: along Wahgi River, 5.94°S, 144.80°E, elev. 1470 m,
Papua New Guinea: Morobe Province: S side Ekuti Divide, 7.42°S, 146.43°E, elev. 1050 m,
The species epithet is a masculine Latin adjective meaning “dressed in black,” in recognition of the dark dorsal and ventral colouration of adults of this species.
A large member of the T. loriae Group (male SVL up to 655 mm, female SVL up to 682 mm) with the following unique combination of characters: sexual size dimorphism in SVL present (t71 = 2.5689, p = 0.0062); two scales covering vent; posterior genials usually entirely separated (80%) but may be in anterior contact (20%) with each other; intergenial usually widest posteriorly (89%) or centrally (11%); preocular usually contacting nasal (77%), not contacting internasal; preocular rather short, less than twice as long as deep; postoculars two (one in 26%); posterior temporals two (58%) or three (42%); ventrals sexually dimorphic (t85 = 7.400, p < 0.00001), 177–206 in males, 187–218 in females; subcaudals sexually dimorphic with overlap (t87 = –24.8814, p < 0.00001), 40–47 in males, 26–41 in females; two scales covering vent; yellow nuchal collar and yellow markings on prefrontals present in juveniles, usually absent (but sometimes merely faded) in adults; tail spine paler than remainder of tail; and venter uniformly dark brown or dark brown with the posterior of each ventral paler brown or yellowish brown in adults, giving a banded appearance, black in life; venter yellow with a black spot on lateral margins of each ventral in juveniles.
Adult Toxicocalamus atratus is easily distinguished from all other members of the T. loriae species group except T. nymani in having a dark venter that is black or very dark brown in life and either uniformly brown or with each ventral banded dark brown in preservative. Other members of this complex have venters that are yellow (T. lamingtoni, T. loennbergii, T. loriae, T. spilorhynchus, T. vertebralis), grey (T. nigrescens), or yellow or pale grey with grey bands across each ventral (T. mattisoni). Toxicocalamus atratus can be distinguished from T. nymani by its juvenile ventral colour pattern (pale yellow with a black spot on the lateral edges of each ventral vs. uniformly black or dark brown but banded with dark brown in preservative in T. nymani), larger size (males to 655 mm SVL, females to 682 mm SVL vs. 422 mm and 540 mm, respectively, in T. nymani), and the greater number of ventrals with overlap in both sexes (males 177–206 vs. 178–198 in T. nymani; t65 = 5.0261, p < 0.00001; females: 187–218 vs. 191–210 in T. nymani, t62 = 4.3472, p = 0.000026). Although the venter of T. atratus is much darker, its banded pattern in most preserved specimens could perhaps be mistaken for the paler banded pattern seen in preserved T. nigrescens and T. mattisoni. Toxicocalamus atratus can be further distinguished from T. nigrescens in having a shorter preocular (preocular approximately squarish, slightly longer than tall in T. atratus vs. more than twice as long as tall in T. nigrescens), and from T. mattisoni in having the preocular usually contacting nasal (vs. never in T. mattisoni) and usually two postoculars (vs. one in T. mattisoni).
Adult female, 590 mm SVL + 72 mm TL = 662 mm TTL. Rostral broader than high, notched ventromedially; internasals angulate, semi-triangular, wider than long; prefrontals distinct from preoculars, approximately square but angled laterally and posteriorly, slightly wider than long (Fig.
Dorsal scale rows 15-15-15, smooth, not notched posteriorly, without apical pits. Ventrals 207, each approximately four times wider than long; two scales covering vent; subcaudals 30, paired. Tail tipped by a pointed conical spine.
In preservative (50 years after collection), dorsum dark brown dorsally, slightly paler laterally (Fig.
Preoculars contact nasals in most specimens but are separated by prefrontal contact with the second supralabial on both sides in 17 specimens and on one side in nine specimens; preoculars are invariably separated from contact with internasals. Postoculars one (25.5%) or two (74%), absent on left side of
Dorsal scale rows invariably 15-15-15. Ventrals 177–206 (196 ± 5) in 49 males, 187–218 (206 ± 7) in 43 females; subcaudals 40–47 (44 ± 2) in 48 males, 26–41 (31 ± 3) in 41 females. SCR 16.9–21.0% (18.3 ± 0.8%) in 48 males, 11.2–17.8% (12.9 ± 1.3%) in 41 females. Tail tipped by a blunt to pointed conical spine. Maximum male SVL = 655 mm, TLR in 38 adult males 12.9–19.4% (15.5 ± 1.7%); maximum female SVL = 682 mm, TLR in 33 adult females 6.7–18.7% (10.2 ± 2.2%); sexual size dimorphism present (t71 = 2.5689, p = 0.0062). There appears to be an ontogenetic effect of tail length in juvenile males, whose tails are relatively shorter (mean TLR 12.5 ± 0.6; n = 10) than those of adult males (mean TLR 15.6 ± 1.7; n = 39). This difference is not present in females (mean TLR in eight juveniles 10.4 ± 1.4, in 32 adults 9.9 ± 1.7). The vent is typically covered by two scales, but this covering is incompletely formed in
Variation in colouration is largely ontogenetic, with adults being black or dark brown above and below, although these colours fade to brown in preservative, and often with each ventral appearing banded with dark and light brown as colouration fades in preservative. Small juveniles (SVL = 161–262 mm) are often paler than this, with a dark vertebral stripe often being present, but this seems to be lost as animals darken ontogenetically. Small juveniles also have a large yellow blotch on each prefrontal and an incomplete yellow nuchal collar whose sides are separated by two to four brown dorsal scale rows (Fig.
Photographs of
Fred Parker, the collector, took numerous field notes on this species in life. Colour patterns for adults were described by him as follows: “Black with pair of yellow spots on the snout, partial bars laterally on back of head.” (
He described the colour pattern for two juveniles as follows: “A juvenile with bright yellow bar across snout and short similar bars laterally on back of head from behind corner of jaw to posterior corners of large head shields but not meeting dorsally. Ventrally, translucent yellow, with a black spot at side of each ventral [scale]. Tail with yellow spike at tip, the spike with small brown tip. Whole of upper lips yellow. Some greyish markings under the head. A narrow dark vertebral stripe. Flanks paler than dorsum. Pair of anals marked grey.” (
Known from the Central Highlands of Papua New Guinea and extending as far east as the southern side of the Ekuti Dividing Range, Morobe Province, at elevations of 840–2140 m (Fig.
Considered common at Kundiawa, Chimbu Province, PNG (Fred Parker, pers. comm.). For example, 88 animals were obtained in gardens on 3 December 1967. In general, most individuals of this species were collected during the day from under piles of vegetation in sweet potato gardens. In forested situations, only the occasional animal would be collected in or under logs during the day. Parker never observed the species active at night, which is consistent with the first author’s experience with other Toxicocalamus species. One specimen (
Parker’s field notes also recorded that
The primary feature distinguishing T. atratus from the very similar T. nymani is the ontogenetic change in ventral colour pattern, which is dramatic in T. atratus but absent in T. nymani. Some populations of T. nymani also retain the yellow nuchal collar and prefrontal spots into adulthood, which individuals of T. atratus never do. Furthermore,
We refer the sole specimen from south of the Ekuti Divide (
The species that appear closely related to Toxicocalamus loriae – based on the phylogeny of
This study increases the number of known Toxicocalamus species from 17 to 23. It seems likely that additional species exist in this species complex for at least two reasons. First, with the exception of the four T. loennbergii specimens from Fakfak in far western New Guinea and one specimen from Angguruk (4.20°S, 139.43°E; ZSM 54/2015), collected in 1979, the western half of the island is completely lacking in specimens of these snakes. This cannot be a true range disjunction and no doubt stems from a lack of reptile surveys over the past century in that large region. Second, we have examined several small snake samples that we cannot assuredly assign to any of the species treated herein. These comprise a total of 19 specimens from nine localities, with samples consisting of merely 1, 1, 1, 1, 2, 2, 2, 3, and 6 specimens/locality, and we include them as Toxicocalamus sp. in the Appendix (including the holotype of the purported taxon T. longhagen). One or two of them may belong to species discussed herein, but at this time we cannot confirm this with confidence. Meanwhile, others show character combinations that are inconsistent with an assignment to the T. loriae Group species as defined herein. Additional material of good preservation quality, combined with good photographs, will be needed to resolve the status of the populations represented in these specimens. Related to this, it will also be of interest to determine whether T. nymani truly contains the two dramatically different colour patterns referred here to that species or whether they in fact represent distinct species that exhibit range overlap on the Huon Peninsula.
These few specimens point to a larger limitation in further resolving species in this taxonomic complex: the need to obtain ontogenetic series for samples from single locations so as to better understand the variation among samples seen among localities with few specimens. We have shown that T. atratus and T. spilorhynchus exhibit ontogenesis in ventral colour pattern, and the same has been demonstrated for T. nigrescens. Ventral colour-pattern ontogenesis may also occur in T. mattisoni and T. goodenoughensis – given the variation described in those species – though sample sizes are too small to be certain. The critical value of ventral colour pattern for identifying species in this complex requires a broader understanding of the degree to which these and other species – both described and undiscovered – vary ontogenetically and among adults. These details need to be documented prior to long-term storage because of the relatively rapid alteration of some colour-pattern details in preservation.
In combination with the work of
Of the 23 species of Toxicocalamus, 12 are restricted to the Papuan Peninsula or its offshore islands, a geological region referred to as the East Papuan Composite Terrane (EPCT,
Since publication of the key to Toxicocalamus in
1a | Subcaudals entire | T. holopelturus |
1b | Subcaudals divided | 2 |
2a | Preocular fused to prefrontal | 3 |
2b | Preocular distinct from prefrontal | 9 |
3a | Frontal fused to supraoculars; ventrals wide, 5–6 times wider than first row of dorsal scales | T. mintoni |
3b | Frontal distinct from supraoculars; ventrals narrow, 3–4 times wider than first row of dorsal scales | 4 |
4a | Internasal distinct from prefrontal; temporal scale separates last supralabial from parietal | 5 |
4b | Internasal fused with prefrontal; temporal fused with last supralabial, allowing supralabial contact with parietal | 8 |
5a | Vent covered by a single scale; 5 supralabials; venter without dark stripes | 6 |
5b | Vent covered by two scales; 6 (rarely 7) supralabials; venter with a pair of longitudinal dark stripes | 7 |
6a | Ventrals 281; last supralabial broader than tall; chin and throat brown; ventrals and subcaudals brown, barred with darker brown; pale nuchal collar absent | T. cratermontanus |
6b | Ventrals 227–255; last supralabial taller than broad; chin and throat white; ventrals and subcaudals white, with or without small brown spots; pale nuchal collar present | T. stanleyanus |
7a | 15 dorsal scale rows at midbody | T. misimae |
7b | 17 dorsal scale rows at midbody | T. longissimus |
8a | Four supralabials; postocular fused with supraocular; 15 dorsal scale rows at midbody | T. buergersi |
8b | Five supralabials; postocular usually distinct from supraocular; usually 13 (rarely alternating between 13 and 15) dorsal scale rows at midbody | T. preussi |
9a | Prefrontal fused to internasal | T. pumehanae |
9b | Prefrontal distinct from internasal | 10 |
10a | Dorsum spotted | 11 |
10b | Dorsum uniformly dark grey or brown, without pale spots | 13 |
11a | Dorsum yellow with a brown spot on posterior of every scale | T. ernstmayri |
11b | Dorsum dark grey or brown with pale spots | 12 |
12a | Pale dorsal scales sparsely scattered across dorsum; venter white | T. grandis |
12b | Almost all dorsal scales except vertebral row with pale yellow spot; ventrals with broad black spot on each | T. spilolepidotus |
13a | Internasal and preocular in contact, separating nasal from prefrontal | 14 |
13b | Internasal and preocular not in contact, separated by prefrontal | 15 |
14a | Habitus robust; nasal divided by large naris; no yellow on prefrontals; venter uniformly brown in life | T. pachysomus |
14b | Habitus slender; nasal entirely surrounds naris; yellow markings on prefrontals; venter dark yellow heavily mottled with dark brown posteriorly | T. goodenoughensis |
15a | Venter uniformly yellow or yellow with mid-ventral row of brown spots | 16 |
15b | Venter brown, grey, black, or yellow barred with grey or brown | 20 |
16a | Two in-line intergenials between posterior genials | T. loriae |
16b | Single intergenial between posterior genials | 17 |
17a | Vent covered by a single scale; dark vertebral line absent | T. lamingtoni |
17b | Vent covered by two scales; dark vertebral line present | 18 |
18a | Single postocular; four infralabials in contact with each posterior genial; snout short (SNL/SNW = 0.93–0.99); pale blotch on each parietal in adults | T. loennbergii |
18b | Two postoculars; three infralabials in contact with each posterior genial; snout long (SNL/SNW = 0.95–1.40); pale blotch absent on parietals in adults | 19 |
19a | Ventrals 172–184 in males, 178–193 in females; subcaudals 20–29 in females; pale blotch on each prefrontal; venter yellow dusted with brown in adults | T. spilorhynchus |
19b | Ventrals 194–210 in males, 203–232 in females; subcaudals 31–38 in females; pale blotches absent on prefrontals; venter uniformly yellow in adults | T. vertebralis |
20a | Venter black in life, banded with brown in preservative; preocular short, slightly longer than diameter of eye, approximately same width as second supralabial | 21 |
20b | Venter grey or yellow in life, banded with grey or brown; preocular long, significantly longer than diameter of eye, longer than second supralabial | 22 |
21a | Juvenile venter black, banded with brown in preservative; body size smaller (male SVL to 422 mm, female SVL to 540 mm) | T. nymani |
21b | Juvenile venter yellow with row of black spots down each side; body size larger (male SVL to 655 mm, female SVL to 682 mm) | T. atratus |
22a | Prefrontal and second supralabial in contact, separating preocular from nasal; venter yellow or grey, banded with brown or grey | T. mattisoni |
22b | Prefrontal separated from second supralabial by contact between preocular and nasal; ventrals grey, banded with darker grey or blackish brown | T. nigrescens |
We thank our many colleagues who made our evaluation of the Toxicocalamus loriae Group possible through loans or by facilitating visits, and providing additional information on specimens, including Cecilie Beatson, Sandy Ingleby, Jodi Rowley, Ross Sadlier, and Dane Trembath (
Examined specimens are listed using their respective museum abbreviations, with the addition of FK (Fred Kraus Field Series numbers). Species are listed alphabetically. Locality names include the country in capital letters, lesser administrative units (e.g., provinces) in small capitals, and specific information (e.g., islands, regions) in regular font.
Toxicocalamus goodenoughensis (n = 2). PAPUA NEW GUINEA, Milne Bay Province: Goodenough Island, Moniu River,
Toxicocalamus lamingtoni (n = 18). PAPUA NEW GUINEA, Morobe Province: Garaina,
Toxicocalamus loennbergii (n = 4). INDONESIA, West Papua Province: Onin Peninsula, north of Fakfak town, elevation 520 m,
Toxicocalamus loriae (n = 19). PAPUA NEW GUINEA, Central Province: Haveri, 9.40°S, 147.60°E,
Toxicocalamus mattisoni (n = 7). PAPUA NEW GUINEA, Milne Bay Province: Mt. Simpson,
Toxicocalamus mintoni (n = 1). PAPUA NEW GUINEA, Milne Bay Province: Sudest Is., Mt. Riu,
Toxicocalamus nigrescens (n = 2). PAPUA NEW GUINEA, Milne Bay Province: Fergusson Is., Basima,
Toxicocalamus nymani (n = 39). PAPUA NEW GUINEA, Madang Province: Maratambu, Adelbert Mts., 5.06°S, 145.47°E, elev. 700 m,
Toxicocalamus pachysomus (n = 1). PAPUA NEW GUINEA, Milne Bay Province: Cloudy Mts.,
Toxicocalamus sp. (n = 19). INDONESIA, Highland Papua Province: Angguruk, Jahûli River, ZSM 54-2015. — PAPUA NEW GUINEA, Eastern Highlands Province: Wonenara, Yaiya Valley, elev. 1650 m,